Exodus 22:12

Christian Standard Bible Anglicised

But if, in fact, the animal was stolen from his custody, he must make restitution to its owner.

Cross References

Genesis 31:39

I did not bring you any of the flock torn by wild beasts; I myself bore the loss. You demanded payment from me for what was stolen by day or by night.

Exodus 22:7

‘When a man gives his neighbour valuables  or goods to keep, but they are stolen from that person’s house, the thief, if caught, must repay double.

Exodus 22:11

there must be an oath before the Lord between the two of them to determine whether or not he has taken his neighbour’s property. Its owner must accept the oath, and the other man does not have to make restitution.

Exodus 22:13

If it was actually torn apart by a wild animal, he is to bring it as evidence; he does not have to make restitution for the torn carcass.